"You talk a load of crap, carrot top" (Anonymous) "consistently good and sometimes bonkers!" (Tony Jones) "You obviously pi$$ people off a lot" "One Dangerous Lady" (Anonymous) "Clearly a very unpleasant person" (Grace Nicholas, Cornwall)
Saturday, 31 July 2010
here they are again!
Jane, your reply above just about sums you up ("where did Labour Friends of Israel come from? I was a member of that for many years - so what?")
It's a bit like saying "I was a member of the Nazi party for many years, so what?"
It matters because it shows that you have no principles of scruples of any kind, in that you think that being a stooge for a racist apartheid state doesn't really matter. You were supposed to represent your Reading constituents, not lobby for a foreign state. It used to be called treason, and the penalty used to be the gallows.
And you haven 't answered my question: How much did did the Israeli government (aka Labour Friends of Israel pay for you?
I suppose we should be thankful for small mercies: you're so inept and incompetent that you couldn't have done the apartheid state of Israel much good.
6 comments:
- Sauti Ndogo said...
-
Jane, I understand how distressing such idiotic comments can be. Nevertheless, surely it's best to resist the temptation to answer them? Their authors are clearly beyond any chance of rational engagement. Ignoring them is the best policy.
- 31 July 2010 at 16:16
-
-
I've never understood why people get personally vituperative about differences of political opinion when it comes to geopolitics. I was a member of the Labour Movement Campaign for Palestine (it was a Trotskyist front in Oxford, and I don't know if it still exists), I was never a Blairite, but I have always thought of you as a friend and ally. The only thing I find annoying is that you know more about foreign policy than I do, so it's hard to win an argument. This galls me.
- 1 August 2010 at 07:11
-
-
It's impossible to have a sensible discussion about Palestine - people just start froth8ing at the mouth and going on about genocide and prison camps. Classic example : ME "If the Israelis wanted to wipe out the Palestinians they's have done it by now" Him :"Well, they're doing it slowly" Me "?????????"
I expect you've seen this, btw :
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/alan-krinsky/8-reasons-leftists-should_b_653432.html - 1 August 2010 at 12:20
-
-
The deranged person making those comments may not be a threat, but such comments have filtered down to educated, middle class Britons form South Asian backgrounds, who have blown themselves up at, or otherwise attacked, targets in Britain and Israel.
The BBC loves debating Israel on its "religious" discussion programmes, and broadcasting nonsense from panellists and the public. They especially like comments from Jews who have rejected Judaism and their community. - 2 August 2010 at 03:52
-
-
Indeed, Anonymous4, I'm seriously concerned by the levels of casual anti-semitism that I hear and read.
- 2 August 2010 at 19:01
-
-
No - ignoring this type of filth is not the 'best policy'. Dirt tends to stick.
Some years ago, the New Statesamn published a piece suggesting that Jane was a racist.
She quite rightly went straight to Carter Ruck and the paper was forced to apologise and pay costs.
If you don't nail this type of thing it is dredged up and quoted against you many months/years down the line as 'fact' in totally different contexts.
Anyone making comments like this knows that if they put their name to them, Jane could sue and win - hands down. A shame they didn't! Jane could then have had a nice and thoroughly deserved pay-out and could have had several shopping trips to Max Mara etc.
SHAME. - 5 August 2010 at 18:24